Year | Recipients | Town |
| 1965 | Charles Chastek
Anthony LaBarbara | Silver Springs
Mt. Morris |
| 1966 | Roy E. Austen
Frank Ricotta | Leicester
Geneseo |
| 1967 | Gordon E. Morse
Rev. Lester Wilcox
Angelo F. Scura | Warsaw
Sonyea
Mt. Morris |
| 1968 | William T. Bruyere
Franklynn M. Stephenson
LaVerne J. Spring | Arcade
Avon
Geneseo |
| 1969 | Donald Gibson
Mr.& Mrs. John Wilcox | Lima
Avon |
| 1970 | John E. Jackson
Martin Gilbride | Castile
Nunda |
| 1971 | Robert Thompson
Arnold Palmer
Hilda Vasciannie | South Lima
Caledonia
York |
| 1972 | Elaine Thompson
Maynard Parlett
William Boyd | South Lima
Pike
Avon |
| 1973 | Robert French
David Hawley | Avon
Arcade |
| 1974 | NONE PRESENTED | |
| 1975 | Edward Lewandowski
Jean Swart | North Java
Avon |
| 1976 | Douglas Johnson
Andrew J. Meekin
Edward & Homosella Lowrey | Geneseo
Geneseo
Conesus |
| 1977 | J. David Konopka
Doris Boyd | Lakeville
Avon |
| 1978 | Bill Monson
Arlie Bennett
Ray Van Duesen | Avon
Geneseo
Conesus |
| 1979 | Pat & Rich Critcher
Jeannette Stevens | Avon
East Avon |
| 1980 | Ronald Ayers
Jake Dziekonski | Geneseo
Avon |
| 1981 | Bob Jesse | East Avon |
| 1982 | W. Jay Humphrey III
Virginia Burnside | Perry
Caledonia |
| 1983 | Fred Hermansen
Cindy Semmell | Caledonia
Avon |
| 1984 | Bob Ossont
Nancy Grisewood | Mt. Morris
Warsaw |
| 1985 | Paul Sick
Bryon Fisher
George Winspear | Avon
Warsaw
Perry |
| 1986 | John Stevenson
Ron Walker
Audrey Brown | Lakeville
Avon
Perry |
| 1987 | Greg Johnson
Paula Knitter
Ken Strathearn | Geneseo
Perry
Pike |
| 1988 | Jeanne Yencer
Russell Hooper
Bob Ciecierega | Perry
York
Geneseo |
| 1989 | Roger Van Valkenburg
Jim Thomson | Warsaw
Geneseo |
| 1990 | Tom Gillette
Edward Hopkins | Caledonia
Avon |
| 1991 | NONE PRESENTED | |
| 1992 | Russ Genco | Mt. Morris |
| 1993 | Bryan French
Mary Jane Halstead
Pat Rountree
Alan Duefee
Tim Bucknam
Russ Johnson | Conesus
Perry
Caledonia
Warsaw
Perry
Livonia |
| 1994 | Dan Murray
John Kent
Peggy Kent
Hugh H. Ten Hagen (Finger Lakes Council) | North Java
Caledonia
Caledonia
Warsaw |
| 1995 | Irene DeClerck
Jack Vosburg | Conesus
Silver Springs |
| 1996 | Rick Tiede
Ruth Herring | Warsaw
Groveland |
| 1997 | Charles Feller
Donald Chapman
Frank Jester | Avon
Leicester
Leicester |
| 1998 | Janice Ayers
Jack Kladke
Craig Nobbs | Caledonia
York
Perry |
| 1999 | John Hettrick
James Barrett | Avon
Piffard |
| 2000 | Beth Feuerstein
Mel Sonnleitner | Geneseo
Fillmore |
| 2001 | Bob Stallworth
Scott Hulburt | Cal-Mum
York |
| 2002 | Bill Louvain
Robin Louvain | Geneseo
Geneseo |
| 2003 | Alice Barrett
Ted Anderson | Piffard
Pike |
| 2004 | Jean Rosier
Cindy Parker | Piffard
Castile |
| 2005 | Fred Scoville
Peter Leblond | Geneseo
Perry |
| 2006 | Clinton Schwab
Scott Gage | Castile
Avon |
| 2007 | Jim Feuerstein
Sandy Streb | Geneseo
York |
| 2008 | Cathy Smith
Guye Smith | Lima
Lima |
| 2009 | Rich Donegan
Scott Canaan | Lima
York |
| 2010 | Jim Yencer
Paul Fleming | Avon
Lima |
| 2011 | Submit Candidates for 2011 (PDF) | |
